Fake It Till You Make It: The Forgotten Art of Teaching Children Self-Control
Somewhere between the authoritarian parenting of yesterday and the permissive parenting of today, we've confused emotional validation with freedom from accountability. But growing up has never meant getting everything you want. It means learning to behave responsibly even when you don't.
The Generation That Apparently Had It Easy
I recently watched a YouTube exchange in which a Gen Z content creator explained why his generation was supposedly superior to Generation X and the Baby Boomers.
Among his arguments was an extraordinary observation: Gen X and Boomers supposedly enjoyed the easiest childhoods because our parents couldn't confiscate our smartphones.
As a Gen Xer, I nearly fell out of my chair laughing.
Apparently, the absence of smartphones meant the absence of punishment.
The Gen Xer responding to the video helpfully reminded his younger counterpart that we had plenty of things our parents could confiscate.
Television privileges. Atari consoles. Bicycles. Time with friends. The telephone. The freedom to go outside.
And, of course, there were additional chores.
Being sent to our bedrooms wasn't particularly entertaining either. We didn't have a portable entertainment center containing thousands of games, millions of videos, and the collected knowledge of humanity.
We had a bed, perhaps a few books, and an excellent opportunity to contemplate our poor decisions.
Then there were six words that could instill existential dread in an otherwise fearless child:
“Wait until your father gets home.”
And occasionally, discipline was physical.
A spanking. A slap. What some parents called a pedagogical slap — a brief physical correction intended to teach a child that a particular behavior was absolutely unacceptable.
Now, I'm not interested in pretending that Generation X had the perfect childhood. We didn't. Some parents crossed the line between discipline and abuse, and some crossed it regularly.
But the exchange raises a question worth examining.
Have we become so concerned with protecting children from negative emotions that we've forgotten the importance of teaching them to tolerate consequences?
And perhaps an even more fundamental question:
Does a child need to understand or agree with a consequence before that consequence can teach them anything?
A Tantrum in a Crowded Mall
Picture a familiar scene.
A parent is shopping with a young child in a crowded mall.
The child sees a toy and demands it.
The parent says no.
The child insists.
The parent repeats the refusal.
And then the screaming begins.
Not ordinary disappointment. Not a few tears. A full-volume, floor-shaking tantrum, complete with kicking, shrieking, and the apparent conviction that every shopper within a hundred meters must participate in this family disagreement.
The parent attempts to reason with the child.
The child screams louder.
The parent offers an explanation.
The child escalates.
Eventually, the exhausted parent has two obvious temptations.
The first is surrender: buy the toy, end the embarrassment, and restore peace.
The second is retaliation: impose an immediate, unpleasant punishment harsh enough to stop the performance.
The first teaches an unmistakable lesson.
Screaming works.
If making a reasonable request doesn't produce the desired result, increasing the volume might.
And if the parent eventually capitulates, the child has discovered an effective negotiation strategy.
The second response introduces a different lesson: unacceptable behavior carries consequences.
But what kind of consequence is appropriate?
And, more importantly, does the child have to understand the parent's reasoning before the consequence becomes legitimate?
To answer that, we need to examine how people actually learn.
Fake It Till You Make It
There's a peculiar assumption lurking in some discussions of emotional development: that appropriate behavior must follow appropriate internal understanding.
First, the child understands why something is wrong.
Then the child accepts the principle.
Finally, the child changes their behavior.
Understanding produces conviction. Conviction produces action.
Except human beings frequently develop in precisely the opposite direction.
Consider courage.
Courage doesn't require the absence of fear. It often consists of acting appropriately despite being terrified.
Consider professional discipline.
An employee doesn't need to enjoy every assignment to learn to complete unpleasant tasks.
Consider politeness.
We routinely expect people to treat others respectfully even when they dislike them.
And consider anger.
An adult who becomes furious with a coworker is still expected to refrain from screaming, throwing furniture, or punching the offending individual.
We don't excuse the behavior because the anger was genuine.
We expect self-control.
Yet nobody seriously believes that every adult who behaves appropriately has achieved perfect emotional harmony.
Sometimes they're furious inside.
Sometimes they're deeply frustrated.
Sometimes they would dearly love to tell someone exactly what they think of them.
But they don't.
They behave better than they feel.
And we call that maturity.
Why should we assume children must first achieve emotional maturity before being expected to practice the behavior that maturity requires?
A child who learns not to hit another person while angry has accomplished something important, even if the anger remains.
A child who learns to accept a refusal without throwing objects has practiced restraint, even if the disappointment remains.
Initially, that restraint may be motivated entirely by external consequences.
But repeated practice can help establish habits, develop self-regulation, and create opportunities for genuine understanding.
In other words:
Sometimes the behavior comes first, and the understanding follows.
That's the essence of “fake it till you make it.”
It isn't a guarantee. Repeated compliance doesn't automatically produce moral understanding. Fear can produce obedience without producing judgment.
But it is a legitimate developmental possibility.
And dismissing outward discipline simply because it precedes internal agreement gets the relationship between behavior and learning backward.
The Pedagogical Slap: What Are We Actually Debating?
This brings us to a controversial subject.
When older generations discuss the so-called pedagogical slap, they aren't necessarily advocating routine beatings, excessive violence, or striking a child whenever they commit some trivial infraction.
The distinction matters.
The argument usually concerns exceptional situations in which a child has repeatedly challenged a serious boundary, refused ordinary correction, and escalated unacceptable behavior.
In that context, some parents defend a brief, immediate physical punishment as a way of communicating that the limit has been reached.
The reasoning is straightforward.
The child was refused the toy.
The child continued screaming.
The child still didn't receive the toy.
And now the child has experienced an additional unpleasant consequence.
Two lessons, potentially learned simultaneously:
First, screaming doesn't necessarily produce the desired reward.
Second, continuing unacceptable behavior can produce consequences worse than the original disappointment.
There's nothing logically contradictory about this argument.
A single experience can teach more than one lesson.
However, recognizing the logic of the argument doesn't establish that physical punishment is the most effective way to accomplish the objective.
And this is where the scientific research becomes important.
The American Academy of Pediatrics explicitly defines corporal punishment to include noninjurious, open-handed hitting intended to modify behavior.
In other words, researchers are not exclusively studying severe physical abuse. They also examine the category of mild physical punishment that defenders often distinguish from abuse.
The Academy's 2018 policy statement, reaffirmed in 2024, concludes that corporal punishment is ineffective as a long-term disciplinary strategy and advises parents against its use.
The World Health Organization's 2025 review reaches similarly unfavorable conclusions.
Those findings deserve serious consideration.
But methodological questions remain legitimate.
How frequently was punishment administered?
How severe was it?
Was the parent acting impulsively or applying a previously established consequence?
What was the child's behavior before the punishment?
What other disciplinary methods were employed?
Did the study distinguish an isolated event from a recurring pattern?
These distinctions can matter, and observational studies cannot always separate them perfectly.
There is also the problem of reverse causation: children with more behavioral difficulties may receive more punishment in the first place, complicating attempts to determine which factors caused later outcomes.
Researchers use longitudinal methods and statistical controls to address such problems, but those methods have limitations.
None of this proves that an occasional pedagogical slap is beneficial.
It means we should distinguish between what the evidence demonstrates, what it suggests, and what remains difficult to isolate.
Most importantly, a punishment's ability to produce immediate compliance does not establish its superiority at producing lasting self-discipline.
A slap might stop a tantrum. But stopping a tantrum and teaching emotional regulation are not necessarily the same achievement.
Nor must discipline be physical to be firm.
A parent can refuse the toy, remove the child from the shopping area, end the outing if necessary, and enforce an appropriate consequence without negotiating away the original boundary.
That, too, teaches that unacceptable behavior has consequences.
And it requires considerable self-control from the parent.
Still, the broader philosophical argument survives regardless of which disciplinary technique we consider appropriate.
A child doesn't need to enjoy the consequence.
A child doesn't need to agree with the consequence.
And the child doesn't necessarily need to understand every reason for the consequence before it can be enforced.
Which leads to a fascinating comparison.
Society Doesn't Ask Whether You Agree With the Rules
Consider how adult society operates.
At home, parents establish rules.
At school, teachers enforce expectations.
At work, employers establish policies.
And in society at large, governments establish laws.
All these systems operate on a principle that is remarkably consistent:
Certain behaviors carry consequences, and the person experiencing those consequences doesn't get to veto them simply because they're unpleasant.
An employee who repeatedly violates workplace rules may be disciplined or terminated.
A driver who exceeds the speed limit may receive a fine.
Someone convicted of a sufficiently serious crime may lose their freedom.
The offender's emotional reaction doesn't nullify the consequence.
A judge doesn't dismiss a lawful sentence merely because the defendant is unhappy about going to prison.
Society doesn't require the offender's enthusiastic cooperation.
But the comparison becomes even more interesting when we consider something that seems almost absurd.
Society can punish people for breaking rules they didn't even know existed.
Ignorance of the Law Is No Excuse
There's a famous legal principle:
Ignorantia juris non excusat.
Ignorance of the law is no excuse.
The principle has deep roots in legal history and remains influential in modern legal systems, although important exceptions and qualifications exist.
Think about what it means.
You can be subject to legal consequences even if you never read the relevant statute.
You may not have known that a particular action was prohibited.
You may not even have realized that a particular legal obligation existed.
Yet ignorance alone will not necessarily protect you from punishment.
Of course, many offenses require proof of intent, knowledge, recklessness, or negligence. The precise requirements vary with the law and jurisdiction.
But the broader principle remains: not knowing a legal rule does not automatically excuse violating it.
And this produces a striking contrast with the way we sometimes discuss childhood discipline.
We expect adults to navigate an enormous and increasingly complicated system of laws, regulations, and obligations, many of which they have never personally encountered.
Yet we hesitate to impose a consequence on a child until the child fully understands and accepts the reasoning behind the rule.
There is a difference, naturally.
Children are developing their cognitive abilities. Parents have a responsibility to explain expectations in age-appropriate terms, and a child's capacity to comply matters.
But the contrast exposes something important.
Understanding a rule, agreeing with a rule, and being accountable under a rule are three different things.
Modern society doesn't always make the third conditional on the first two.
And neither can effective parenting.
Even the Supreme Court Recognized the Problem
The legal principle is not absolute.
In 1957, the United States Supreme Court decided Lambert v. California, a case involving a woman convicted of failing to comply with a Los Angeles registration requirement applicable to people with certain prior criminal convictions.
The Court considered the fact that she had not been shown to know about the requirement and that there was no demonstration that she was reasonably likely to have known about it.
Her violation consisted of passive failure to register, rather than an affirmative act that would ordinarily alert someone to potential legal obligations.
The Supreme Court reversed her conviction.
The ruling recognized that due process can require notice, or circumstances making knowledge of a duty reasonably probable, before certain criminal penalties may be imposed.
This did not abolish the general principle that ignorance of the law is no excuse.
It established a narrow constitutional limitation on its application.
And that limitation is instructive.
Because even a legal system that permits punishment without actual knowledge of every rule recognizes that authority must have boundaries.
The government cannot simply declare every conceivable punishment legitimate because someone technically violated a law.
The lawfulness of the consequence matters.
The circumstances matter.
The protections afforded to the individual matter.
Authority is necessary. Unlimited authority is not.
And that principle applies to parenting as well.
Authority Does Not Require Agreement
Here's where I believe the discussion becomes especially relevant.
We often confuse the right to express disagreement with the right to disregard a decision.
They're not the same.
A child is entitled to dislike a parental rule.
An employee may consider a workplace policy foolish.
A citizen may believe a law is unjust.
In a free society, people must be able to question authority, challenge decisions, and advocate changing rules.
Indeed, some of society's greatest moral achievements have come from people refusing to accept unjust systems.
But disagreement doesn't automatically suspend every obligation.
And frustration doesn't entitle someone to violate another person's rights.
A child who is told they cannot have a toy may be disappointed.
They may protest.
They may even become angry.
But they don't acquire the right to assault someone, destroy property, or throw a tantrum to compel the parent to purchase the toy.
Likewise, a parent who possesses legitimate authority doesn't acquire unlimited permission to exercise it however they please.
A police officer's authority to arrest doesn't authorize an unnecessary beating.
A prison's authority to incarcerate doesn't authorize torture.
And a parent's authority to discipline doesn't automatically establish that physical punishment is justified.
The legitimacy of imposing consequences and the legitimacy of a particular method of punishment are separate questions.
We need to be able to defend the former without automatically endorsing every example of the latter.
Otherwise, we end up with one of two equally defective conclusions.
Either all uncomfortable consequences become suspect because they distress the person receiving them.
Or all punishments become acceptable because the authority imposing them is legitimate.
Neither position is defensible.
The Difference Between Teaching Obedience and Teaching Responsibility
There is another objection frequently raised against externally imposed discipline.
A child who obeys because they fear punishment hasn't necessarily internalized the moral principle behind the rule.
That's true.
But it doesn't follow that externally motivated obedience is worthless.
Consider why adults refrain from committing crimes.
Some do so because they believe the behavior is morally wrong.
Some because they fear the legal consequences.
Most likely, many people's decisions involve a combination of moral convictions, social expectations, habits, and practical considerations.
The resulting behavior can be identical despite different motivations.
Society doesn't require a person to achieve philosophical enlightenment regarding property rights before expecting them not to steal.
The rule applies regardless.
Over time, external expectations can become internal habits and convictions.
That doesn't happen automatically, and punishment alone is a poor substitute for moral education.
But the process is familiar.
Children initially follow many rules because adults require it.
Later, they may understand the practical reasons behind those rules.
Eventually, they may accept the principles as their own.
This is not necessarily a failure of moral development.
It can be part of moral development.
A child who initially refrains from hitting because the parent will impose a consequence may later discover that hitting damages relationships, hurts people, and makes conflicts harder to resolve.
The external boundary creates an opportunity to practice the behavior while understanding develops.
That's the distinction I believe we've been neglecting.
We shouldn't require complete internal agreement as a prerequisite for reasonable external behavior.
Sometimes self-control must be practiced before it can become habitual.
But Not Every Tantrum Is Defiance
There is an important qualification.
Not every screaming child is deliberately testing authority.
Children can become overwhelmed by fatigue, sensory stimulation, fear, hunger, or emotions they haven't yet developed the ability to regulate.
A crowded shopping mall can be an exhausting environment even for adults.
And a toddler's capacity to manage frustration is not equivalent to that of an older child, much less an adult.
From across the aisle, deliberate defiance and genuine dysregulation can look remarkably similar.
That matters because effective discipline requires understanding what the child is capable of doing.
A child who knows a rule and can follow it but chooses not to presents a different challenge from one who lacks the developmental capacity to regulate their behavior at that moment.
Both may require intervention.
Neither requires rewarding destructive behavior.
But the interventions need not be identical.
Sometimes a consequence is appropriate.
Sometimes the immediate priority is simply removing the child from an overwhelming environment.
Sometimes the lesson must wait until the child is calm enough to understand it.
Accountability must account for capacity. Otherwise, it stops being education and becomes arbitrary punishment.
Gen X Wasn't Indestructible, and Gen Z Isn't Doomed
Of course, no essay about childhood discipline would be complete without addressing the generational mythology surrounding it.
Generation X likes to remember itself as the generation that survived unsupervised afternoons, garden hoses, bicycles without helmets, and parents who rarely knew our exact location.
There's truth in those memories.
We developed independence partly because we had opportunities to exercise it.
We learned to solve problems without immediately consulting an adult.
We discovered that scraped knees, lost games, failed experiments, and disappointing afternoons weren't necessarily emergencies.
But that doesn't mean every aspect of our upbringing deserves celebration.
Some children experienced genuine neglect.
Some endured excessive punishment.
Some learned to conceal distress rather than manage it.
And some became resilient despite their childhood experiences, not because of them.
Likewise, Gen Z isn't uniformly fragile.
Young people today face challenges that previous generations didn't encounter in the same form, including the pressures of permanent online visibility, pervasive social comparison, and an environment in which mistakes can follow someone indefinitely.
Expressing anxiety doesn't necessarily demonstrate an inability to handle it.
And silence isn't proof of emotional strength.
But this doesn't invalidate the criticism that some children are being deprived of opportunities to experience frustration, failure, and meaningful consequences.
The problem isn't that younger generations have emotions.
Every generation has emotions.
The problem arises when adults teach children, deliberately or otherwise, that experiencing an unpleasant emotion means the environment must change to eliminate it.
That's not empathy.
It's a misunderstanding of what emotional development requires.
The Parent Must Also Learn Self-Control
Here is perhaps the most uncomfortable part of the entire argument.
If we're going to demand self-control from children, we must demand it from parents too.
Return to the shopping mall.
The child is screaming.
Other shoppers are staring.
The parent's patience is rapidly evaporating.
The easiest solution may be to buy the toy.
Another tempting response may be to strike the child and hope the screaming stops.
But a parent who refuses the demand, calmly removes the child from the situation, and follows through on a reasonable consequence is demonstrating precisely the behavior they're trying to teach.
The parent is frustrated.
The parent is embarrassed.
The parent may be furious.
Yet the parent remains in control.
That doesn't make the boundary weak.
It makes the enforcement deliberate.
And when the child becomes capable of listening, the parent can explain the consequences without retracting them.
There is no contradiction between empathy and authority.
A parent can say:
“I understand that you're upset.”
And then:
“The answer is still no.”
Both statements can be true.
The child doesn't have to stop feeling upset before the boundary can be enforced.
Nor does the parent have to stop caring about the child's feelings in order to enforce it.
A good boundary doesn't disappear when someone cries. And a good parent doesn't stop caring when someone misbehaves.
Children Are Not Entitled to a Consequence-Free Childhood
The broader issue extends far beyond the debate over spanking.
Children need boundaries because adults need self-control.
Children need to experience disappointment because adults cannot expect every desire to be fulfilled.
Children need to encounter consequences because adult society imposes them, sometimes with considerably greater severity than anything a parent would reasonably contemplate.
And children need to understand that their feelings, however genuine, do not confer unlimited rights over other people.
A child may feel furious.
That doesn't justify hitting someone.
A teenager may feel betrayed by a parental restriction.
That doesn't establish that the restriction is unjust.
A student may feel humiliated by a poor grade.
That doesn't mean the teacher is obliged to award a passing mark.
An adult may feel that a particular law is unfair.
That doesn't automatically exempt them from its enforcement.
Naturally, rules can be wrong.
Authorities can abuse their power.
Consequences can be disproportionate.
And individuals must retain the ability to challenge injustice.
But the existence of unjust punishments does not mean that punishment itself is unjust.
Nor does the existence of abusive discipline invalidate the necessity of discipline.
These distinctions should be obvious.
Yet much of the argument surrounding parenting seems determined to erase them.
The Real Lesson
I don't believe Generation X developed resilience because its parents had more opportunities to inflict punishment.
Nor do I believe Gen Z is destined to collapse because its parents were generally more attentive to emotional well-being.
But I do believe we've lost sight of something fundamental when we treat every unpleasant childhood experience as something to be prevented.
Growing up involves learning to behave responsibly even when doing so is difficult.
It means accepting that other people have rights.
It means tolerating frustration.
It means fulfilling obligations.
It means understanding that the world will not always accommodate our preferences.
And it means learning that consequences can be legitimate even when we dislike them.
Sometimes they can be enforced before we understand their full rationale.
Sometimes we may never agree with them.
And in adult society, we may even face legal consequences for violating rules we didn't know existed, subject to the protections and limitations established by law.
That reality doesn't justify cruelty.
It doesn't establish that a slap is the best way to teach discipline.
It doesn't require us to rehabilitate every parenting practice of the past.
But it does challenge the notion that a consequence becomes illegitimate simply because it is imposed involuntarily, causes distress, or precedes complete understanding.
The purpose of parenting isn't to produce a child who never cries.
It isn't to produce someone who obeys every authority without question.
And it certainly isn't to produce someone who behaves appropriately only when threatened.
The purpose is to help a developing human being become an adult capable of exercising freedom responsibly.
Someone who can distinguish between feeling something and acting on it.
Someone who understands that rights come with responsibilities.
Someone who can challenge unjust authority without rejecting the very concept of accountability.
Someone who can hear “no,” feel disappointed, and continue behaving like a civilized human being.
We don't have to bring back every disciplinary practice of the 1980s to teach those lessons.
But we shouldn't abandon the lessons simply because some of the old methods were wrong.
A child doesn't have to like a consequence to learn from it.
A child doesn't have to agree with a boundary to respect it.
And a child doesn't have to feel mature before learning to act maturely.
Because ultimately, self-discipline isn't the absence of frustration, anger, or disappointment.
It's the ability to behave responsibly despite them.
And sometimes, the journey toward that ability begins with something as simple — and as difficult — as doing the right thing before you fully understand why.
Fake it till you make it.
References and further reading
American Academy of Pediatrics. Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children. Pediatrics, December 2018; reaffirmed June 2024.
World Health Organization. Corporal Punishment of Children: The Public Health Impact. August 2025.
World Health Organization. Corporal Punishment of Children and Health. May 2026.
Supreme Court of the United States. Lambert v. California, 355 U.S. 225. December 16, 1957.
Gen Z Has 3 Reasons Why They're Better Than Gen X. YouTube video that prompted the discussion.

Comments
Post a Comment